Is abortion moral or immoral essay

However, there seem to be a number of issues to address: The Court describes the right to abortion as "fundamental. That utilitarianism is an aggregative theory — different individuals' satisfactions or frustrations are added, or summed, or totalled - is the key objection to this theory.

No mandatory waiting period Waiting period of less than 24 hours Waiting period of 24 hours or more Waiting period law currently enjoined Abortion counseling laws in the U. Utilitarianism fails in this respect and so cannot be the theory we seek.

First of all it puts the question Is abortion moral or immoral essay a wider context: A pregnant woman must convince two doctors of the medical grounds for an abortion, either due to her own physical or mental health, or the health and future happiness of the baby.

The case is no different when we examine the ethics of our treatment of animals. Rousseau gave us the idea of the social contract, Kant, the idea of the legislature of moral beings existing in a kingdom of ends and coming up impartially so to speak with some idea of the common good and universal rights that guarantee this summum bonum.

The question of who has inherent value is such a question, one that is resolved more rationally without the introduction of the idea of immortal souls than by its use.

Among such thinkers the sort of view now favoured is one or other form of what is called contractarianism. Kant applied to abortion How does all this apply to the issue of abortion? The words I have written here and in other places by themselves don't change a thing.

He saw clearly, and rightly, that the natural law tradition had used sanctions to try and force us to act in a way that is contrary to our desires, by using fear and punishment. Contemporary Political Philosophy click here for her essay For Channel 4 factsheets on abortion go to: That's what I have been exploring over the past ten years or so in my essays and talks and, most recently, in my book, The Case for Animal Rights.

When it comes to the case for animal rights, then, what we need to know is whether the animals that, in our culture, are routinely eaten, hunted and used in our laboratories, for example, are like us in being subjects of a life. Thus young children, for example, are unable to sign contracts and lack rights.

But there are many, many humans who fail to meet these standards and yet are reasonably viewed as having value above and beyond their usefulness to others.

More generally, all of our duties regarding animals are indirect duties to one another — to humanity. That is where our duty lies, according to the rights view. So you are the one who is wronged, not your dog.

As a trained and practising philosopher, the sort of contribution I can make is limited but, I like to think, important. Cruelty in all its guises is a bad thing, a tragic human failing. The deed can be done. And I would say, if only people since Kant had taken this way of deriving the right choice more seriously, we might not have got the twisted thinking of Mein Kampf or the disastrous misjudgement of the Iraqi war.

What could be the basis of our having more inherent value than animals? A utilitarian accepts two moral principles. He must overcome a huge hurdle in the person of Hippocrates, the "Father of Medicine," and his famous Oath which has guided medical ethics for over 2, years.

It is not surprising that many people share this distorted view of Roe v. Supreme Court case Griswold v. How do we answer the metaphysical question — when does the foetus have human rights?

A second possibility is that though both humans and your dog are hurt when kicked, it is only human pain that matters. Utilitarianism has no room for the equal moral rights of different individuals because it has no room for their equal inherent value or worth.

What Would The Punishment Be If Abortion Were Illegal?

Let those who are the victims of injustice suffer as they will. Pain is pain wherever it occurs. Though the medical profession expressed hostility toward feminism, many feminists of the era were opposed to abortion. Despite the familiar, reassuring ring of these ideas, I do not believe that this view offers an adequate theory.

By separating out emotion from reason he gives us a method of avoiding the sort of emotive debate we often find in the tabloid press.

Ten Legal Reasons to Reject Roe

Both stem from views about the sanctity of human life and the wrongness of preventing a potential human being, knit together by God from conception, from developing. Justice Rehnquist's dissent in Casey notes that the Court "has overruled in whole or part 34 of its previous constitutional decisions" in the past 21 years.

It is our hearts, not just our heads, that call for an end to it all, that demand of us that we overcome, for them, the habits and forces behind their systematic oppression.

My last two points are about philosophy, my profession. In making his argument, the speaker uses the conventional, textbook-approved order of argument from Swift's time which was derived from the Latin rhetorician Quintilian.The Holy Bible Containing the Old and New Testaments: The culmination of English translations of the Bible, the publication of the American Bible Society’s King James Version features full-text searchability, content-based tables of contents and a quick verse finder.

Indeed, it has been concluded that compulsory population-control laws, even including laws requiring compulsory abortion, could be sustained under the existing Constitution if the population crisis became sufficiently severe to endanger the society. Abortion in the United States has been, and remains, a controversial issue in United States culture and politics.

Various anti-abortion laws have been in force in each state since at least Before the U.S. Supreme Court decision Roe v. Wade decriminalised abortion nationwide inabortion was already legal in several states, but the. The Moral Status of the Foetus: Philosophical Investigations into the Abortion issue The Nature of the Problem.

Click here for the current state of UK law on abortion. An embryo is defined as biological human life from 14 days to eight weeks.

An examination of the possibilities for libertarian feminism, taking the feminist thought of the 19th century radical individualists as an example and a guide. We find that the radical libertarian critique of statism and the radical feminist critique of patriarchy are complementary, not contradictory, and we discuss some of the confusions that lead many libertarians--including many libertarian.

Banning Prayer in Public Schools Has Led to America's Demise.

What Would The Punishment Be If Abortion Were Illegal?

By Editorial Staff Published May 1, by Gary Bergel. A recent statistical analysis by David Barton graphically illustrates how America has plummeted from righteous living, prosperity and success in the last quarter century.

Is abortion moral or immoral essay
Rated 3/5 based on 38 review